Bitcoin and its Quest for Gold's Crown

By Nastasha Firdaus Khan

The creation and subsequent rise of Bitcoin has famously challenged traditional financial structures and ignited along-standing debate: can this digital asset dethrone gold as the ultimate store of value?  


A Hedge Against Uncertainty


Historically, gold has served as a safe haven during periods of economic turmoil. What this basically means is that when traditional markets falter, investors flock to gold, seeking refuge from inflation and currency devaluation. This flight-to-safety behavior has propelled gold prices upwards during globally alarming events such as the 2008 financial crisis, where gold surged over 30% as traditional assets plummeted. 

Bitcoin, with its limited supply and decentralized nature, has emerged as a strong potential alternative. Crypto maximalists strongly argue that Bitcoin has the potential to inevitably act as a successful digital hedge against inflation. However, Bitcoin’s extent of success here is still arguable. 

Take the pandemic for example. During the initial market panic of COVID-19 in March 2020, both gold and Bitcoin initially witnessed price drops. However, Bitcoin recovered much faster, showcasing its potential resilience in a black swan event. In fact, after what was dubbed as the ‘pandemic crash’ in March of 2020, the following months saw the start and eventual boom of the crypto bull market where prices for top blue-chip cryptos soared over 700%. 

Another prominent example is the United States' Federal Reserve's quantitative easing (QE) programs, implemented post-2008 and during the pandemic, have been linked to rising gold prices. However, the impact on Bitcoin has been less clear. While some correlation exists, Bitcoin's shorter history and higher volatility make it difficult to definitively link price movements to QE policies. 


The Evolving Landscape


Bitcoin's adoption as a mainstream asset class is still in its nascent stages. Regulatory uncertainty, scalability limitations, and its volatile nature remain significant hurdles in its journey to dethrone gold. 


Gold's Enduring Allure

Gold possesses certain advantages over Bitcoin. It has a long and established track record as a store of value, with a proven ability to hold its worth over centuries.  

Unlike Bitcoin, which exists solely in the digital realm, gold is a physical asset. You can hold it, store it, and even admire its beauty. This tangibility fosters trust and a sense of security for investors, particularly those wary of the intangible nature of digital assets. 


Gold has also served as a store of value for over 5,000 years. From ancient civilizations to modern economies, it has consistently held its worth across empires, wars, and economic upheavals. This long historical record offers a level of trust and confidence unmatched by the nascent Bitcoin. 

Other than that, gold has an inherent utility beyond being a store of value. It's used in jewelry, electronics, and even medicine. This intrinsic value provides a safety net – even during periods where its investment appeal wanes, gold retains a core value due to its necessity in industrial applications. Bitcoin, on the other hand, lacks such inherent utility (for now). 

Historically, gold has exhibited a strong positive correlation with inflation. When fiat currencies lose purchasing power, gold prices tend to rise, protecting investors from wealth erosion. While Bitcoin's track record against inflation is shorter, some evidence suggests it might follow a similar pattern. However, gold's longer historical performance offers more reliable data. 


A Complex Dance

The relationship between macroeconomics, Bitcoin, and gold is intricate. While Bitcoin exhibits some characteristics of a ‘safe haven asset’, its short (and at times turbulent) history and inherent price-action volatility make it a less established hedge compared to gold. 

Government regulations surrounding Bitcoin remain a major hurdle for mainstream adoption. Uncertainty and restrictive policies can deter institutional investors and limit its growth. Conversely, clear and supportive regulations can foster trust and accelerated option, potentially boosting Bitcoin's price. 

As Bitcoin matures and navigates future economic crises, its performance will be closely scrutinized. Will it solidify its position as a digital gold, or will it remain a speculative asset susceptible to broader market fluctuations? Only time will tell if Bitcoin can truly usurp gold's throne. 

Ordinals and Runes despite their individual challenges, represent a collective effort to enhance Bitcoin's functionality and usability as the ecosystem evolves and matures. Ordinals, by enabling the inscription of data onto individual Satoshis (smallest unit of Bitcoin), unlock novel use cases. This opens doors for digital art, music, and potentially even legal contracts directly on the Bitcoin blockchain. An expanded range of applications can make Bitcoin more relevant and attractive to a broader user base. 

However, Ordinals also raise concerns about scalability and potential misuse. The data attached to each Ordinal increases the transaction size, which has at times led to higher fees and slower confirmation times. Additionally, the permanent nature of inscribed data raises questions about potential misuse for illegal content. 

Runes, the latest protocol involving Bitcoin scripting language founded by Casey Rodarmor, has the potential to unlock more advanced functionalities on the Bitcoin blockchain. This could enable features like smart contracts, conditional payments, and multi-signature wallets directly on the Bitcoin blockchain. These functionalities could potentially enhance Bitcoin's utility and inevitably become more appealing and relevant to a wider range of users, including businesses and developers. 

The narrative of Bitcoin replacing gold is often oversimplified. Both assets offer unique attributes. While Bitcoin's digital nature and limited supply hold immense potential, its big upswings and downswings in price action volatility and short history still warrant a far more cautious approach. 

The future may not be a binary choice between Bitcoin and gold. Instead, we might witness a scenario where both assets coexist, catering to different investor needs. Bitcoin may appeal to tech-savvy individuals seeking a digital hedge (much like what the landscape is shaping up to be now), while gold might retain its allure for those favoring along-established safe haven. 

Ultimately, the true test lies in Bitcoin's ability to navigate future economic storms. If it consistently demonstrates its value proposition as a reliable store of value, then the conversation about dethroning gold might gain significant traction. However, for now, the dynamics between macroeconomics, Bitcoin, and gold remains a complex dance with an uncertain outcome. 

Photos: Generated by AI, Google

Join TrustXPay’s waitlist here!


May 3, 2024